New Years' in Boston. There's one fundamental thing even experienced photographers forget... |
My wife and I got Covid just before Thanksgiving (then I got it again), so we were down for a month and that's why you haven't heard much from me lately. In the meantime there's so much to share that I'm just going to do a huge data dump this month. I'll keep it all short. Here we go. (As always, click on any image to make it larger and sharper!)
1) Sometimes the Old Ways are Best
Look at the green focusing square. The camera focused on something reasonably close, not the face. |
I've been friends with one of my readers for many years. He takes pictures of his town's annual Christmas parade. He owns an OM Digital (Olympus) OM-1 and a Sony A7R V, and this year he wrote to me with a few complaints.
Complaint 1: Facial Recognition doesn't recognize Santa Claus. Sure, we all recognize Santa, but the camera can't always see a mouth or recognize a full face. And it's pretty apparent that the machine learning algorithms weren't trained on a data set that included Santa.
Solution 1: Rather than relying on automation, you can fall back to the time-honored technique we used back in the olden days: Switch to spot focusing mode, then Focus Lock -> Recompose > Shoot. Nails it every time.
Yes, he shot in RAW and was able to recover from this poor exposure, but that's not the point. |
Solution 2: Even matrix metering may work great under a greater set of non-ideal conditions, but when conditions are really awful the old ways are best. Switch to Spot Metering mode, lock the exposure with AEL, recompose and shoot.
With many cameras it's possible to combine both of those things in one ridiculously fast operation. I've been using these techniques for more years than I care to admit, they work every time. No more blaming my equipment! :-)
2) New Year's in Boston and the Importance of This One Essential Tool
We attended Boston's famous New Year's celebration called First Night. Lots of free concerts and events. And lots of decorative lights. The best time to take such shots is called the "Blue Hour" (about an hour after sunset), but most cameras of any manufacturer will get the exposure for such shots wrong.
Keep in mind that if there's no face present in the shot, your camera's default metering method is to pretend there's no color information and then render what's left so it averages out to 18% grey. (This is tied to the legendary 18% grey card, which you may have learned about in your anthropology class. :-) ) For shots like this, and also for fireworks (which always seem to be blown out when in AUTO mode), your secret weapon is the old Exposure Compensation control. Usually underexposing by -1.3 stops (for lights) or -2 stops (fireworks) will override the camera's tendency to wash everything out and make it look like the way your eye and brain remember seeing them.
(Yeah, it's kind of basic, but even experienced photographers need reminders of when the camera will get it wrong and what to do about it.)
Exposure Compensation is my most-used camera control. |
3) Marie's story
In a Catholic church in the Vietnamese city of Hue, there stands a statue of Phaolô Tong Viet Buong. When Emperor Ming Mang began a new round of persecutions of Christians, he ordered the apostasy of Christian soldiers; Phaolô refused. He was arrested in 1832, spent a year in prison being tortured, interrogated for the names of other Christians, and ordered to renounce his faith; Phaolô refused. He was finally convicted of being a Christian, kicked out of the army and was beheaded. Pope John Paul II later made him a Saint.
His great great great great granddaughter, now 87 years old
and living in Southern California, saw this image I took of his monument when I was there in 2018 and
started to cry. She grew up in Hue
(pronounced, "Whey") just before the Vietnam war; spent two years in a
labor camp before escaping to the Philippines.
She got married in this
church. And she's never returned to her
home country because there was no family left, and it would bring back too many
negative memories. She told me this story before I embarked on the trip, and I went out of my way to bring home these pictures to her.
Every artist wants their work to invoke an emotional reaction when viewed. I'm lucky to have witnessed it a handful of times in my life.
4) Updates
The Spanish version of the Sony A6700 book has been released!
The .epub and .azw3 versions of the English A6700 book have been released!
A Spanish translation of the A7CR / A7C II ebook is in the works.
And yes, I'll be writing a book on the upcoming Sony A9 III. I'm especially anxious to try shooting flash outdoors at 1/10,000th of a second and have the background come out black. :-) (Also looking forward to shooting in theaters without shutter noise and without banding.)
5) Seminars
Remember, only four seminars per year. Here's how the schedule for 2024 is shaping up:
6) First Thursday Gallery Walk
For those of you who are still willing to compromise your mental health by remaining on Facebook, there's an online art group called First Thursday Gallery Walk to which I'm a contributor. Come join the group, gaze at a stream of member-curated art, and contribute your favorite pieces! The group home page is here. Every time I see something I like (not all of it photography) I share it there.
7) Safari Update
One third of the available seats are already taken, and it's only January! Come participate in an African safari designed specifically for the unique needs of photographers, taking place November, 2024. Learn more and join us at https://FriedmanArchives.com/safari !
8) Charles Bronson - Man with a Camera
Wikipedia adds, "Besides an array of cameras for normal use, for surreptitious work Kovac employs cameras hidden in a radio, cigarette lighter and even his necktie. He also has a phone in his car, and a portable darkroom in the trunk where he could develop his negatives on the spot."
This was Charles Bronson's only lead in a TV series. And ironically, the B&W work on that show was good but not great. The American TV show Rawhide (starring a young Clint Eastwood) easily surpassed it with its technical superiority - perfect lighting and zone system-like placement of greys and skin tones. All of the B&W TV shows in the 1960's were like that. It's as if all the TV cinematographers had an epiphany all at once or something.
You can view the entire series on youtube.
9) Next Time in Cameracraft Magazine
The older I get, the more difficulty I have finding old pictures. I often see other people’s images come across via text, of snapshots that are old but over time have taken on increased sentimental value. Where is the high-resolution version of that image? I want to share it!
There are lots of online image similarity detectors. Google Images lets you upload an image and in a split second it will show you where it exists on the internet. Tineye.com does the same thing. But these tools only work for images that are online. I want a tool that allows me to give it a picture and it will show me where on my local hard drives that image exists. Better yet, I need a program that finds images that are close to what I feed it – perhaps the one before I rotated and did some editing or cropping or resizing in Photoshop.
So I set out to find the right tool – most were awful and just crashed while indexing my hard drives. And in the current issue of Cameracraft magazine, I share what I discovered; what worked and what didn't. Subscribe to Cameracraft magazine today to read about what I learned!
(My new official slogan is, "I beat my head against the wall so you don't have to!" (tm))
10) Best Phone App Ever Invented
(Warning: this has little to do with photography.)
Every time I see a product that has been brushed with genius, I like to tell the world about it. For example, back in the mid-1980's I was amazed by a program called Creator/Notator, a music notation and MIDI sequencing program that ran on the Atari 1040ST computer. It could capture what you played, quantize it to any required degree, and print it out like a music publisher. It had a graphical user interface and could update the musical score in real time as you played. It had a 16-track MIDI sequencer that could accompany your playing and even track you if you sped up or slowed down. It could handle SMPTE time code so it could accompany your other tracks on your multi-track recorder. And so much more. I'll admit that my description doesn't do its capabilities justice (this web page does it better), but perhaps even more impressive is that the whole program fit onto a single 720kb low-density floppy disk, making it obvious it was all written in assembly language. (Compare that to all the Microsoft software available at that time, which would be distributed on perhaps 10 or 14 high-density floppies and not nearly as sophisticated!). Pure genius.
That was impressive back then. Here's what's impressing me now: Let's say you're a Lego enthusiast (you know, the plastic bricks that you inevitably step on with bare feet when you're a parent) and you have a LOT of Legos lying around. Spread them all out on the floor and take a picture of it, and use the BrickIt app (iOS or Android) and it will analyze what you have and suggest different figures you can build using the bricks in your collection, including step-by-step directions. All from a phone-resolution image!! Check out this YouTube video showing it in action.
Are you impressed, or what? :-)
Okay, that's enough for one blog post. Happy new year!
Until next time,
Yours Truly, Gary Friedman
I'm still doing grantwriting for the MIT program mentioned here. As part of our mission of turning good engineering students into great systems engineers, we also want to attract new talent from groups other than white males. Contributions accepted! :-) |
Come back and give a seminar in Los Angeles. Please!
ReplyDeleteEntirely possible, as we have grandkids out there. Stay tuned!
DeleteAny camera is better than no camera, especially when it is capable of video. This is something I never witnessed before:
ReplyDeletehttps://www.smugmug.com/gallery/n-6QKhKd/
The final image was my Christmas card this year: Off with the old, on with the new.
Great images!
DeleteCan you record a seminar, so we can enjoy it?
ReplyDeleteAsk and you shall receive! :-) https://FriedmanArchives.com/seminars and click on "Get the Streaming Version".
DeleteJust to clear up for readers, Blue hour is about an hour AFTER sunset, or before sunrise.
ReplyDeleteWhoops! Fixed. Thanks for keeping me honest! :-)
DeleteRe Google image search/recognition (#9).
ReplyDeleteSearching a hard drive is entirely different than searching the web.
On the web, Google has the benefit of a billion queries like yours, whether those were successful (the user downloaded the image, or if not, how they tweaked their search, and what they eventually chose). That’s a huge amount of information and guidance.
Whereas searching a hard drive is a basically brute force sifting through and comparing a smaller (but still large) set of images.
For instance, unless your input image is a really exact copy of another, the first situation is much easier and more likely to find something very close to what you want.
Further belaboring the point … I have gmail and frequently search it. The results are disappointing compared to Google web search because web search has no problem with misspelled , poorly framed questions by drawing on a billion previous searches.
ReplyDeleteBut searching my email, unless I can recall the exact text I once wrote, Google can’t “extrapolate”. I get no “best guesses” the way I would on the web.
Your second point is good when it comes to Google trying to figure out what you probably meant to search for. When it comes to searching for similar images, though, I would argue that the process is the same whether on the web or on your hard drive: Search and index first, then look for closest matches.
DeleteWhen Google founder Larry PAGE is having a vision of AI as a replacement for Google Search : https://www.perplexity.ai/search/Larry-Pages-vision-phcFpFiYTuSZT9NUJiMKyA
DeletePerhaps you've been heard... :) I even think we can expect AI to be used soon for private home services.
Great Post. I learned a lot. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteImpressive accomplishments. Thanks for sharing. (I still have my HP41 from my engineering days)
ReplyDeleteReally? Me too! What are the odds? 😄
DeleteLove your first tip on spot focus. As good as the subject recognition algorithms are, they also have their own prioritizations (e.g. persistently grabbing the wrong face in a crowd, or seeing faces where none are present, or not seeing faces where they are) - always good to know how to wrest control back to get what you need to get that shot.
ReplyDeleteRegarding your second tip - I'm not familiar with the Olympus / OM systems, but with Sony's live-view option and running in full manual (which I trust more in bad lighting situations), you should be able to see if your subject is properly exposed. However, at least in older models (I'm still on the A7R3, so cannot speak to the newer ones) you also must set the Creative Style to "Neutral" or else your RAW file will not at all reflect what you shot, and will still be metered to the brighter areas (even if you are using spot metering), and the live view will show you the applied style even if not shooting in JPG - this drove me batty and compromised a lot of high DR shots, until I found others with the same issue. I'm wondering if that also is what caught your friend, as it's a little discussed quirk with the Sonys that you only notice in really tricky situations.
I think that's a really good point! Since RAW files are simply data pulled from the sensor and sent straight to the card, the image can't reflect whatever .jpg enhancements you have set using features like Creative Styles. You're also right about using the exposure compensation control to make bad light look better, but that takes a little time and when you're shooting subjects that don't cooperate (like a parade) the luxury of time may not be available. I'll suggest this to my friend!
ReplyDeleteAbout BrickIt: Being a software engineer starting in the 60s and remembering what you had to do to store programs on cassette tape and floppys, given the advancement to today, even I would have said that program was impossible. Shows how old I'm getting. I can see how you were amazed.
ReplyDeleteKeep up the good work
Gary,
ReplyDeleteUnrelated to this blog, but I'm looking forward to your thoughts about the new A9iii. Have you had a chance to use one yet? Will you be publishing a book for it? Do you think global shutter will be the future standard for digital photography? Sony revolutionized digital woth mirrorless, then Canon and Nikon followed; do you think they will follow Sony with global shutter?
Thanks!
Greg
Hi, Greg. I'm in Norway right now but will work on the A9 III book in earnest once I return later this month. Although I can't predict the future, I would guess that in 20 years global shutters will become the norm. It solves a lot of technical problems (especially when shooting under LED lights) and with enough volume will eliminate the need for the mechanical shutter, saving manufacturing costs.
Delete