So here I was, preparing to lead a photo safari in Africa, when David Kilpatrick, editor of Cameracraft magazine, sent me a message: “I’m going to write an article about several different lenses, including the Sigma 150-600mm EF lens (Canon mount) with converter, and adapting this Canon fit kit to Sony”, he says. “Good timing”, I said, “I’m going to be testing two 600mm lenses while in Africa. Why don’t we do a comparison?”
So we started planning.
I arranged for a loan of two additional lenses for testing, making a
total of 4 lenses on my side of the pond. The four lenses were:
1. The Sigma 60-600mm f/4.5-6.3 DG DN OS Sports Lens (Sony mount) – the 10x range appealed to me for the Africa trip, since it meant I wouldn’t have to change lenses much and risk getting dirt on the sensor. Price: $1,920 USD.
2. The Sony RX10 IV, my favorite travel camera since it has an incredible 24-600mm (35mm equivalent) lens permanently attached to the lightweight body. It achieves this portability by employing a small, 1”-type sensor. Price: $1,698.
3. The Sony FE 200-600mm f/5.6-6.3 G OSS Lens, Price: $1,898
4. Sony FE 600mm f/4 GM OSS Lens, which costs a mere $12,998 (!)
Due to a comedy of shipping errors, I wasn't able to use all of the lenses all at once.4 giraffes with Mt. Kilimanjaro in the background. |
Optically, this lens is outstanding. |
Lucky shot. :-) |
Me holding the Sigma 60-600mm lens |
Top: Sony 600mm f/4 GM. Middle: Sony 200-600 f/5.6-6.3 G Bottom: Sony RX10 IV |
Bokeh comparison at 600mm: Left: 600mm at f/4 Center: 200-600 at f/6.3 Right: RX10 IV at f/6.3 |
Left: 600mm f/4. Center: RX10 IV at 600mm Right: RX10 IV image photoshopped to match the 600mm f/4. There! I just saved $11,300. Now I can send one of my grandkids to college for a week. |
Here I am doing my Mark Galer impersonation with the 600mm f4. |
I have a lot more to say about these lenses, including how they all handled, which one had me cursing out loud (multiple times per day!) and which one I'll be taking with me next time I go on a safari. All will be revealed in the next issue of Cameracraft magazine, to which you can subscribe here. Digital subscriptions are only 15 GBP per year!
In the Pipeline
I'll be starting the book on the Sony A1 II just as soon as mine arrives, and I'm fixin' to have it ready by the end of March. You can pre-order it at a discount here.
Also coming up next month is an article about my trip to Uganda. I was there to document what I believe is a Nobel-prize-worthy effort by a Yale professor who has spent the last 20 years identifying a bacterium responsible for neonatal infections causing sepsis and hydrocephalus in the region. Now he's working on understanding how the babies get infected, and is organizing an army of over 800 medical ambassadors whose job will be part prenatal care and part medical ambassador to the villagers who are skeptical of modern medicine. It's an amazing story.
And in February there will be a full trip report on the Kenya experience, including shots and impressions from the participants. Stay tuned!
Wireless Flash Workshop
Just before the Africa trip I conducted my 2nd Wireless Flash Workshop for a local photo club. And I can't tell you what a positive impact it had on the participants. I designed it to help people overcome their understandable phobia of this intimidating technique by first providing a lecture and a real-time demonstration, and then had the attendees break up into groups of three and try to duplicate some sample shots I had created. At first you could hear the frustration as people tried to get their hands around all the variables, but after a short time it "clicked" (no pun intended) and started getting outstanding images! By the end of the half-day event I could hear people leaving and exclaiming what a worthwhile exercise that was - it got them over the learning curve hump and had inspired them to experiment further with this important technique.If you know me at all you know just how much I love wireless flash, and if you've seen my wireless flash sample gallery on the FriedmanArchives.com website you understand just how much dramatic impact it can add to your photography.And so I'm considering taking this half-day workshop on the road. It doesn't require a 2-day committment like the Friedman Archives High-Impact Photography Seminars (which people also rave about, BTW), and I can casually conduct some of these on our next road trip back to California.
So let me know if this would be of interest to you! Fire off an email to Gary at Friedman Archives dot com and let me know where you live and I'll start planning!
Parting Shot
Back in my NASA days I had applied to MIT for graduate school. Didn't get in, even though I was able to demonstrate the kind of well-roundedness (i.e., not just just pure science and engineering) that the Media Lab said they were looking for. (More about that here, which you might find to be an interesting read.)But based on my volunteer work for the past several years at the MIT Beaver Works Summer Institute, I'm now an affiliate. Not the same as getting a degree there, but in hindsight I think my life ended up just fine without it.
Until next time,
Yours Truly, Gary Friedman
Excellent work, Gary. I would like to say something that I think I have repeated more than a thousand times during my long life as photographer: "I have a lot of cameras and lenses, but I heve NEVER enjoyed and appreciated the quality of a camera, lens and sensor combination as much as I have enjoyed with the Sony RX10M4, which I still have and use occasionaly today.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the validation! Every time I call Sony Pro Support I mention they need to make an RX10 V. The guy at the other end usually responds with, "Yeah, we hear that a lot."
DeleteI also enjoy using the RX10M4, but it has failed me in humid environments, even without getting wet. When in a drier climate, it works great and a convenient package for travel, as you say. Bring on the M5 model!
DeleteI've used my RX10M4 in very humid environments including the cloud rainforests of Ecuador, the Galapagos, Costa Rica rainforests, Bolivia Amazonia, etc. - never any issues with the camera, luckily.
DeleteI use my RX10M4 for most of my shooting. I had an M3 before that. It got a lot of condensation on it at sunrise on top of Cadillac Mountain and kept on ticking with no problems.
DeleteMost frustrating camera I ever used. Bought for a trip, sold when I got home.
ReplyDeleteThere was an adjustment period for me too. The designers wanted the camera to be ideal for videographers as well as still photographers. Hence the motorized zoom which is responsible for the long turn-on / turn-off times. Sorry to hear of your frustrations with it!
DeleteThe camera takes only a couple seconds to turn on. Why anybody would find that a problem I don't understand. I shoot sports with my RX10iv so I leave the camera on all the time.
DeleteI want to add that I shoot RAW and process with DXO PL8 which allows me to use up to ISO 6400 with good results. Only when I need ISO above that does my A99ii come into play.
DeleteIf you think RX10iv is difficult try moving to A7RV after 30 plus years using Minolta, Konica-Minolta and Sony A-mount cameras and lenses! It's gives whole new meaning to "lesrning curve". I wish Sony had just made it point & shoot with all settings automatically setup for the user. If course I jest (but with some sincerity).
DeleteP. S. Gary tried commenting using Google but when I do it sends back to top then when I scrolled back down to open comment Anonymous is selected and no option to use Google sign in. Does that mean I'm signed in as Google? This new blogger setup is as confusing as switching to E-Mount from 30+ years of A-mount. GEGJR aka George
I would definitely be interested in attending your Off-Camera flash workshop!
ReplyDeleteI've been using my RX10iv for years and despite owning a full frame A99ii with 7 lenses covering 15-600mm I rarely use it preferring the RX10iv.
ReplyDeleteEnjoyed your trip to Africa with long lenses. I have the Tampon 150-600 Nikon Mount. Works great and for less than the lenses you tested. Interesting, your connection to MIT Media Lab. I was the last graduate student to pass through the MIT Creative Photography Laboratory, S.M.Vis.S., 1984, the year the Media Lab took over. We both did reasonably well with and without MIT. Mark Strand, Fargo, ND
ReplyDeleteI know it's a typo but I got a chuckle out of the "Tampon" 150-600 lens. Who knew they were such a multi-faceted company.
DeleteI found "tampon" remark hillarious, too.
DeleteDear Gary,
ReplyDeleteI'm following your blog for a long time already and wanted to leave a comment now, because it just fits perfectly.
I own a A77 and the A77M2 (and read your fantastic books for both cameras).
Just came back from a trip to Costa Rica and decided just before to get the RX10M4 and also read your amazing book to get all setup.
This camera is just AMAZING! Without changing lenses it just covered everything and without the 600 mm I would have been totally lost with all those animals there.
(have to admit that I have to get used to the on-off-times with the zoom lens too at first, but not a major problem I have to say).
Really appreciate your work!
Kind regards from Germany.
Marc
Looking forward to you lens summary. I sold my Sony 200-600 shortly after I bought it, too slow and not the sharpest lens I've worked with. Anxious to get your feedback on the Sigma
ReplyDeleteI just snagged a Sony 70-400mm F4-5.6. I'm excited to shoot at 600mm w/ my a77ii!
ReplyDeleteGreat blog, as always. I'm not a professional photographer but an avid amateur. I'm also officially an old tired person. I love, love, love my Sony RX10IV! I bought after trying a 200-600 lens for a trip to Alaska. I lifted that lens out of the box, felt its weight and said, "That ain't happening," and bought the Sony. I haven't looked back. It's not perfect (my iPhone does a better job with indoor light much of the time) but I've taken it on two trips to the UK and it never felt heavy or awkward. And I got some great shots.
ReplyDeleteHi Gary, glad to hear the excitement over your trip. I am excited to hear more about it.
ReplyDeleteIn meantime, as you may or may not remember, this past September 2024 I traded in my A77MII and A99MII along with a couple of Tampon oops, :-) LOL (I hope my attempt at humor isn't bad taste) Tamron lenses to get the 7RV and LA-EA5 (I also purchased your e-book to help me get past the incredible learning curve from A-mount and help me get acquainted with the new menu system) so I could continue using the 70-400 A-mount until I can afford to buy either an E-mount 200-600 or 100-400. I catch the 24-105 F4 A-mount on sale just before Thanksgiving so it is my first mirror less lens purchase. I am anxiously awaiting your critique of the 200-600 and 100-400. Ordinarily I would have kept the A77MII and A99MII but I don't want to maintain two lens mount systems. Besides I am considering getting a used RX10IV as a backup camera.
As much as I'd like to attend your seminar on wireless flash I have been a follower of yours about wireless since the good old Monica amino it's 7D days.. In fact I still have and use my 5600HS-D!
BTW, I tried to read scribe to the digital camera craft magazine but was unsuccessful. Does the digital version still exist and is available in USA?
correction "Monica amino" Minolta, Konica-Minolta
DeleteHi Gary, I gegjrphotography@outlook.com wrote the comment published December 16, 2024 at 10:25AM. For some reason I am unable to logon to the blog. Thanks George.
ReplyDeleteOh, hi George! It's always fun to try to figure out the name of an anonymous poster. :-) Anyway, YES, digital subscriptions are available and it's unfortunate that it's listed on the RIGHT side of the subscription page, about 3/4 of the way down, where it says "Subscribe to Cameracraft". It's only 15 GBP per year!
DeleteWhat about the Leica-branded 100-400mm f/4-6.3 lens for micro four thirds? At 600mm equivalent focal length, I’d bet it would stack up well against this bunch, and it is almost as compact as the RX-10.
ReplyDeleteI haven't personally tried it but it stands to reason that would be an ideal combination! The two biggest concerns are sharpness and bokeh. (And a Leica lens is no doubt sharp! :-) :-) )
DeleteI am responding to anonymous post about A77M2 and 70-400mm G2 lens. I've had 70-400mm G2 for several years. Used it on A77M2 and A99M2. I think it's a marvelous lens. Just be aware if you use it with TC2.0 you will lose 2 stops so best to use on a very bright day or you'll need to bump up the ISO.
ReplyDeleteI've since sold the A77M2 and A99M2 but kept 70-400mm to use with LA-EA5 on my newly acquired A7RV until I can afford to buy a 100-400mm.
Dear Gary,
ReplyDeleteI loved my Sony RX 10 III, and so I once asked you if I should upgrade to the RX 10 IV, and of course, you said yes. (Naturally I did buy your guide-book!)
And I never looked back! I took thousands of photos with my trusting RX 10 IV, and even though I try to keep too much dust and water from her, the camera works still fine after two times getting a swell of salt water over her (both times in an boat, once in the North Sea, once in Greenland).
I used the camera everywhere, from the Arctic to the red dust of Namibia. Never did she let me down, and other photographers are very often very astonished about the quality of my pictures. Some even question their expensive and heavy equipment and say they may be buying the RX 10 IV instead (three friends of mine actually did).
After I learned this fall that Sony won't produce the camera anymore, I went so far and bought a second (new) one as an substitute, should something happen to my first one (a fall, or getting stolen, or a fault which can't been repaired anymore...). This seems a bit extreme, but there is no camera on the market, not from any manufacturer, which can substitute the Sony RX 10 IV. And that's very sad, because the model is seven years old already...
It's a shame that Sony apparently won't produce a RX 10 V; my theory is, that the RX 10 is too good and is internal competion to at least their APS-C models. (And for all lenses, of course.)
Seasons greetings from Germany!